NYC man Carlos Ortiz, who allegedly shoved woman on subway tracks, acted in self-defense: attorney

The person charged with shoving a woman onto the subway tracks in Instances Sq. was appearing in self protection, his lawyer claimed at his first court docket look on Saturday.

Carlos Ortiz, 32, is accused of snatching a girl’s belongings on the forty second Road subway station, then pushing her onto the tracks of the northbound R practice, in response to police.

However Ortiz’s lawyer, Francis White of Authorized Support, argued that witnesses who spoke to police and the media unfairly assumed his consumer to be a “mugger,” or “snatcher.”

“It appears the individuals have a really weak case,” White stated.

“He’s clearly – even by their idea to some extent – a sufferer, somebody who was attacked by girl who falls into the subway.”

Female apparently robbed and pushed to subway tracks at Times Square station.
The girl was transported to Bellevue Hospital following the incident.
Peter Gerber

On Friday round 1:45 p.m. Ortiz allegedly grabbed a girl’s belongings on the forty second Road subway station then pushed her onto the monitor for the northbound R practice, in response to police. Bystanders rapidly jumped into motion, serving to her off the tracks again onto the platform and even nabbing Ortiz as he tried to flee, holding him till police arrived on scene, cops stated.

The 36-year-old girl was transported to Bellevue Hospital with head accidents. Ortiz was arrested and charged with assault on Friday after a witness recognized him in a police lineup, officers stated.

Ortiz appeared raveled in court docket on Saturday, sporting a grimy grey sweatshirt.

“We’ve a state of affairs right here the place somebody fell right into a subway as a part of an altercation so the supposed good Samaritans assumed that the pusher was a mugger and a perpetrator, and made statements to the police, or to the press, or somebody to that impact,” White stated.

“Assuming that what appeared to occur was my consumer was accosted by somebody and he was defending himself,” White added.

Video proof of the assault seems to point out the sufferer hitting Ortiz moments earlier than he pushed her on the tracks, Assistant District Lawyer Jacqueline Sudley revealed.

Carlos Ortiz, who allegedly shoved a woman at the 42nd Street subway station, claims he did it in self-defense.
The 36-year-old who was shoved on the subway platform handled head accidents.
Peter Gerber

“This can be a critical case the place the defendant stands accused of pushing a girl onto the subway tracks after an altercation, inflicting the lady to be hospitalized with a critical head damage,” Studley stated on Saturday.

“There’s a video of the complainant assaulting or trying to assault the defendant within the moments previous the defendant pushing the complainant onto the subway tracks,” she stated. “There’s additionally an eyewitness that said the complainant was placing the defendant previous to the push.”

White requested that Ortiz be freed on supervised launch, however that request was denied by Choose Robert Rosenthal, who set his bail at $5,000 money and $30,000 bond. The prosecution had requested bail be set at $20,000 money.

Carlos Ortiz, who allegedly shoved a woman at the 42nd Street subway station, claims he did it in self-defense.
Carlos Ortiz’s lawyer claims he “was defending himself,” in opposition to the ladies he allegedly shoved onto the subway tracks.
Peter Gerber

“This can be a very robust risk that there will likely be a horrible miscarriage of justice if bail is ready,” White stated. “My consumer is described in newspapers as a homeless individual. Clearly he can not make bail.”

Ortiz has one prior misdemeanor cost in New York, in response to Studley, with two different misdemeanor convictions in Connecticut, for which he served one yr in jail after offering legislation enforcement with two separate names. He additionally had a number of warrants in 2014 for expenses akin to aggressive merchandising and trespassing. These expenses had been all dismissed, besides one the place he made $1 bail.

His subsequent court docket look will likely be on Thursday, Nov. 18.

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul responded to the alleged assault on Friday, vowing to make town’s public transportation system safer.

“I’m horrified {that a} girl was pushed onto the tracks on the Instances Sq. subway station at this time, and I’m hoping for her full restoration,” she said in a tweet Friday. “I’m working with @MTA and our Metropolis companions to make our transit system safer. Nobody ought to experience the practice or stroll the streets in worry.”

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous post Dallas, we have an information technology problem
Next post Art installation at Bigelow Lab takes deep dive into ocean health